Butter Vs. Mayo Grilled Cheese Taste Test

Somebody told us that mayo on the outside of a grilled cheese works better than butter. We had to investigate. Were they right or were they wrong?

Butter Vs. Mayo Grilled Cheese Taste Test

Have you heard of putting mayo on the outside of your grilled cheese sandwich instead of butter? This idea first came to me via my cousin on Facebook where he swore that it was the best thing ever. I tried it back then and agreed that it worked, but I’d never done a side-by-side butter-mayo comparison. Our Grilled Cheese Series here on The Cookful seemed like the right time to test it out properly.

We made two sandwiches using plain white bread and processed cheese slices, in classic American grilled cheese style. Then we spread softened butter on the outside of one and mayonnaise on the outside of the other. They both went into a skillet warmed over low heat and cooked until both sides were toasty brown. Here they are:

Butter Vs. Mayo Grilled Cheese Taste Test

The results of our grilled cheese taste test!

Convenience:

First, we’ll say that using mayo is more convenient than using butter because it’s always soft and ready to spread. If you don’t already have butter at room temperature, then you need to soften it before spreading. Margarine is an alternative here but none of us tend to have margarine in our fridges (wow, when did we become such food snobs?).

Taste:

As to the actual taste, there were two of us tasting the sandwiches that day. In the side-by-side test, neither of us preferred the slightly tangier mayonnaise version. We liked our sandwiches tasting like bread and cheese only, it seems.

Texture:

For the texture and appearance, the butter version had a more even browning but the mayonnaise sandwich looked very nice. The mayonnaise one was crisp where browned but the bread beneath the browning was fluffier, which was a nice soft thing to bite through. The bread on the butter sandwich was a bit drier throughout and on the overly crisp, maybe even crumbly, side.

Conclusion:

On the outside of a grilled cheese sandwich, mayonnaise is more convenient and yields a nicer texture. However, the taste is not ideal. We still prefer traditional butter, but, if there’s no butter softened on your counter, do reach for the mayo. You’ll be pretty happy with the results for sure.

Christine Pittman

Christine is the Founder and Senior Editor of The Cookful. She also blogs at COOKtheSTORY where she specializes in easy healthy homemade recipes. Healthiness aside, she has been known to shred cheese onto a dinner plate, microwave it for 30 seconds, and then eat the messy goop with a spoon.